For owners of convenience store portfolios contemplating their exit strategy, the focus often centers on showcasing overall profitability and market share. However, in today’s sophisticated mergers and acquisitions (M&A) landscape, buyers are digging deeper, seeking portfolios that not only demonstrate strong current performance but also present a clear path for future growth and a compelling return on investment.  

Two powerful levers retailers can strategically employ to significantly enhance their portfolio’s valuation and deliver an attractive Internal Rate of Return (IRR) to potential acquirers are 1) well-executed divestment decisions and 2) strategically deployed growth capital initiatives. 

The Power of Strategic Divestment: Pruning for a Healthier Return

Just as a gardener carefully prunes plants to encourage robust growth and maximize yield, convenience store retailers looking toward an exit should strategically evaluate their portfolio for underperforming or non-core assets ripe for divestment. The decision to sell off certain stores might seem counterintuitive when the goal is to present a large and impressive network, but in reality, a well-considered divestment strategy can yield significant benefits that directly translate to a higher overall valuation and a more appealing IRR for buyers. 

Of course, when considering divestment decisions, it’s crucial to have a clear understanding of your portfolio’s performance. Identify stores that consistently fall below performance benchmarks, don’t align with your long-term strategic goals, or are located in markets where you lack a strong competitive advantage. Then let go of your weakest links. When you do, you will: 

• Improve Overall Portfolio Performance: Underperforming stores can act as anchors, dragging down the overall financial metrics of your portfolio. By shedding these weaker assets, you immediately improve key indicators such as average revenue per store, average profitability, and overall EBITDA. This presents a much more compelling financial picture to potential buyers. 

• Enhance your overall valuation multiple: Critically evaluate each store to identify locations that enhance your overall valuation multiple versus those that dilute it. Often, divesting lower-performing stores that would command a lower multiple can increase the average multiple of your remaining, stronger portfolio, ultimately leading to a higher total company value. 

• Concentrate Focus on Core Strengths: Divesting non-strategic locations allows you to concentrate your management efforts and capital resources on your most profitable and high-potential stores. This demonstrates a clear understanding of your core markets and strengths, which is highly attractive to acquirers. 

• Reduce Operational Complexity and Risk: A streamlined portfolio is inherently easier to manage and operate efficiently. Buyers often perceive less risk in a portfolio without the complexities of managing disparate and underperforming locations, which can lead to a higher valuation. 

• Increase Buyer Confidence: A portfolio that has been strategically pruned signals a proactive and disciplined management team that isn’t afraid to make tough decisions for the long-term health of the business. This instills greater confidence in potential buyers regarding the overall quality of the remaining assets. 

• Free Up Capital for Strategic Initiatives: Selling off non-core or underperforming assets generates capital that can be strategically reinvested in higher-growth areas of your core portfolio, further enhancing its value and appeal to buyers. 

While selling off some of your stores might involve a short-term reduction in the total number of locations, it’s easy to see how the long-term benefits to your overall portfolio’s valuation and attractiveness can be substantial. 

Fueling Future Value: The Strategic Deployment of Growth Capital 

Once strategically pruned, the next powerful lever for enhancing valuation and IRR is the smart, targeted deployment of growth capital initiatives within your core assets. When a sale is on the horizon, the approach to growth capital differs significantly from the approach used in a long-term ownership scenario. In exit mode, strategic investments should lead to exceptionally high returns. Not only will these initiatives boost EBITDA and valuations, but they will also likely increase the multiples you command, dramatically improving your overall exit valuation. 

Consider: A $1 million investment in your stores yielding an additional $200k in annual EBITDA could be worth $1.6 million at sale with an 8X multiple. This valuation increase, combined with the increased annual EBITDA leading up to the sale, delivers a very compelling IRR, significantly amplifying your portfolio’s appeal to potential buyers. So, what kind of growth capital initiatives can deliver a strong IRR and boost valuation? The most promising investments include:  

• Store Modernization and Remodeling: Investing in upgrading the physical appearance and functionality of your stores can dramatically enhance customer experience, increase foot traffic, and drive higher inside sales. Modern layouts, improved lighting, updated restrooms, enhanced merchandising, and improved curb appeal can all contribute to a stronger bottom line and a higher perceived value. 

• Technology Integration and Upgrades: Implementing or upgrading technologies such as advanced point-of-sale (POS) systems, mobile ordering platforms, loyalty programs, and data analytics tools can significantly improve operational efficiency, enhance customer engagement, and provide valuable insights for future growth while enhancing your earnings and providing a significant return at the time of sale. Buyers are increasingly looking for retailers who have embraced technology to stay competitive. 

• Expansion of High-Margin Offerings: Investing in expanding or improving high-margin offerings like foodservice programs, proprietary coffee blends, or enhanced beverage selections can significantly boost profitability. Buyers are particularly attracted to portfolios with strong and growing revenue streams from these higher-margin categories. 

• Strategic Merchandising Initiatives: Investing in data-driven merchandising strategies to optimize product placement, enhance the customer shopping experience, and drive impulse purchases can lead to increased sales and profitability. 

• Energy Efficiency Improvements: Investing in upgrades that reduce energy consumption not only lowers operating costs but also appeals to environmentally-conscious buyers, potentially increasing the valuation of your portfolio. 

• Developing or Acquiring Strategic Locations: While divestment focuses on shedding non-core assets, strategically investing growth capital in acquiring or developing new stores in high-growth or underserved markets that complement your existing portfolio can significantly enhance its overall value and future potential. 

No matter where you choose to invest, growth capital, strategically aimed at driving future revenue and profitability, is crucial for maximizing your exit value. 

The Synergy of Divestment and Growth Capital: A Powerful Formula for Max Value and Strong IRR 

The most effective approach to maximizing your convenience store portfolio’s valuation and delivering a compelling IRR often involves a strategic combination of both divestment decisions and growth capital initiatives. First, prune to create a stronger, more focused foundation. Then, strategically deploy growth capital in your core, high-potential stores, to demonstrate a commitment to future growth and profitability. 

This two-pronged strategy presents a compelling narrative to potential buyers, justifying a higher valuation multiple while clearly demonstrating the potential for a strong return on investment. Buyers will recognize the enhanced efficiency, reduced risk, and clear growth prospects, making your portfolio a highly desirable acquisition target. 

Time to Talk Strategy. If you’re contemplating an exit, we can help you take a fresh look at your portfolio and start proactively making tough decisions about which assets to shed and which are most worthy of investment dollars. Our conversations are always confidential and insight-driven, never high-pressure. Reach out to discuss long-term value enhancement and strategic preparedness. Learn more about our comprehensive Mergers & Acquistions capabilities.

Let’s Get Started